Date:

12/17/05

Red Team:

Sean Taylor,
Dave Warth,
Kelly Buttermore,
Kristina Sepulveda,
Ale Kolleeny,
Stephen Kelly

Votes:

15

Blue Team:

Ernie Privetera,
Louie Pearlman,
Mo Fathelbab,
Harry Conroy,
Michelle Dobrawsky,
Mike Hagen

Votes:

9

Winner:

Red

Candy:

Snickers
Cruncher

Josh Fulton

Date:

12/10/05

Red Team:

Sean Taylor,
Dave Warth,
Kelly Buttermore,
Kristina Sepulveda,
Ale Kolleeny,
Stephen Kelly

Votes:

14

Blue Team:

Alan Fessenden,
Jen MacNeil,
Pat Baer,
Erin Rose Foley,
Maddy Mako,
Steven Slate

Votes:

8

Winner:

Red

Candy:

Hershey's
Special Dark

Matt Pack

Date:

12/03/05

Red Team:

Tony Carnevale,
Dave Warth,
Kelly Buttermore,
Kristina Sepulveda,
Ale Kolleeny,
Stephen Kelly

Votes:

11

Blue Team:

Dave Thunder,
Ryan Morrison,
Louie Pearlman,
Mo Fathelbab,
Mike Hagen,
Terry Jinn

Votes:

7

Winner:

Red

Candy:

Hershey's
Symphony

Sam Rogal

Date:

11/26/05

Red Team:

Dave Thunder,
Dave Lombard,
Rosemary Stevens,
Sean Taylor,
Rylan Morrison

Votes:

7

Blue Team:

Jen MacNeil,
Michael Jeffrey Cohen,
Steve Kornstein,
Rylan Morrison
Terry Jinn

Votes:

8

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

KitKat

Rylan Morrison

Date:

11/19/05

Red Team:

Heather S.,
Roland Satterwhite,
Nick Gibbons,
Maddy Mako,
Zach Tabacco,
Shelly Stover

Votes:

7

Blue Team:

Jen MacNeil,
Judy Peterson,
Andy Rocco,
Michael Jeffrey Cohen,
Steve Kornstein,
Terry Jinn

Votes:

14

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

PayDay

Dave Thunder

Date:

11/12/05

Red Team:

John Conroy,
Amanda Allan,
Becky Yamamoto,
Shawn Wilkens,
Lex Morales,
Sarah McLean

Votes:

10

Blue Team:

Jen MacNeil,
Andrew Mendillo,
Andy Rocco,
Michael Jeffrey Cohen,
Kristina Sepulveda,
Terry Jinn

Votes:

14

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

3 Musketeers

BJ Gallagher

Date:

11/5/05

Red Team:

Mark Lee,
Rosemary Stevens,
Dave Warth,
Bob Acevedo,
Babs Singer,
Pat Baer

Votes:

5

Blue Team:

Jen MacNeil,
Pete Olson,
Ptolemy Slocum,
Dave Thunder,
Kristina Sepulveda,
Terry Jinn

Votes:

12

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

Kit Kat

John Frusciante

Date:

10/29/05

Red Team:

Kristina Sepulveda,
Dave Lombard,
Matt Pack,
Rebecca Siegel (Batgirl),
Pat Baer (ShadowTracker),
Alex Marino (Asmodeus)

Votes:

9

Blue Team:

Kevin Cragg,
Maddy Mako,
Steve Kornstein,
Dave Thunder,
Kevin Hines,
Terry Jinn

Votes:

18

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

Snickers

Amanda Allan

Date:

10/22/05

Red Team:

Amanda Caggiano,
Tony Carnevale,
Jeff Scherer,
Rebecca Siegel,
Louie Pearlman,
Michael Jeffrey Cohen

Votes:

7

Blue Team:

Kevin Cragg,
Maddy Mako,
Steve Kornstein,
Dave Thunder,
Kevin Hines,
Terry Jinn

Votes:

11

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

Almond
Joy

Dan Buchbinder

Date:

10/15/05

Red Team:

Kevin Hines,
Garrett Palm,
Louie Pearlman,
Dave Lombard,
Damon Ketron,
Steve Kornstein

Votes:

9

Blue Team:

Kevin Cragg,
Maddy Mako,
Devlyn Corrigan,
Dave Thunder,
Matt Sloan,
Terry Jinn

Votes:

19

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

Chew-ets
Peanut
Chews

Paul Nichols

Date:

10/8/05

Red Team:

Kevin Hines,
Garrett Palm,
Louie Pearlman,
Dave Lombard,
Ptolemy Slocum,
Steve Kornstein

Votes:

9

Blue Team:

Kevin Cragg,
Danielle Cook,
Devlyn Corrigan,
Dave Thunder,
Ryan Rogers,
Terry Jinn

Votes:

9

Winner:

TIE

Candy:

Date:

10/1/05

Red Team:

Dyna Moe,
Kirk Damato,
Louie Pearlman,
Dave Lombard,
David Weiner,
Nick Gibbons

Votes:

13

Blue Team:

Becca Siegel,
Ernie Privetera,
Mike Sleap,
Griffin Newman,
Ezra Miller,
Katarina Kojic

Votes:

11

Winner:

Red

Candy:

M-azing
Peanut
Butter

Amanda
Allan

Date:

9/24/05

Red Team:

Dan Goodman,
Tony Carnevale,
Joe Albert,
Dave Thunder,
Justin Lamb,
Nick Gibbons

Votes:

14

Blue Team:

Mo Fathelbab,
Louie Pearlman,
Jen MacNeil,
Carl Arnheiter,
Dave Furfero,
Michael Jeffrey Cohen

Votes:

9

Winner:

Red

Candy:

Hershey's
Kit Kat
Coffee

Elana
Fishbein

Date:

9/17/05

Red Team:

Kevin Cragg,
Tony Carnevale,
Dave Lombard,
Dave Thunder,
Jessica Bell,
Nick Gibbons

Votes:

27

Blue Team:

Garrett Palm, Megan Rees,
Madalyn Mako, Eden
Gauteron, Mike Hagen,
Dave Warth

Votes:

9

Winner:

Red

Candy:

Hershey's
Snickers
Almond

Shelly
Stover

Date:

9/10/05

Red Team:

Kevin Cragg,
Tony Carnevale,
Dave Lombard, Rebekka Johnson,
Jessica Bell,
Nick Gibbons

Votes:

14

Blue Team:

Garrett Palm, Megan Rees,
Madalyn Mako, Vickie
Schmitt, Mike Hagen,
Dave Warth

Votes:

14

Winner:

TIE
(rematch
next show)

Candy:

Nestle
Oh Henry!

Michelle
Dobrawsky

Date:

9/03/05

Red Team:

Louis Pearlman,
Michelle Dobrawsky,
Steve Kornstein, Frank Campy,
Andy Rocco,
Jawnee Conroy

Votes:

10

Blue Team:

Garrett Palm, John Fldala,
Madalyn Mako, Matt
Donnelly, Mike Hagen,
Carl Arnheiter

Votes:

11

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

Nestle
Crunch w/
Peanut
Butter

Aldon
Ford

Date:

8/27/05

Red Team:

Greg Jardin,
Michelle Dobrawsky,
Erik Tanouye, Kevin Cragg,
Silvija Ozols,
Matt Moses

Votes:

18

Blue Team:

Shelly Stover, Tiffany Morningstar,
Erin Rose Foley, Matt
Pack, Pat Baer,
Lemar McLean

Votes:

6

Winner:

Red

Candy:

Hershey's
Cookies &
Cream

Dave
Thunder

Date:

8/20/05

Red Team:

Rosemary Stevens,
Dominic Dierkes, Jen
MacNeil, Alex Marino,
Amanda Allan,
AJ Morales

Votes:

6

Blue Team:

Shelley Stover, Tiffany Morningstar,
Erin Rose Foley, Matt
Pack, Pat Baer,
Lemar McLean

Votes:

15

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

Cadbury
Flake
Dipped

Steve
Kornstein

Date:

8/13/05

Red Team:

Rosemary Stevens,
Kevin Cragg, Jen
MacNeil, Alex Marino,
Amanda Allan,
Dave Thunder

Votes:

8

Blue Team:

Kevin Hines, Alan Fessenden,
Steve Kornstein, Dave
Lombard, Dave Warth,
Michael Jeffrey Cohen

Votes:

5

Winner:

Red

Candy:

Hershey's
Skor

Becky
Yamamoto

Date:

8/6/05

Red Team:

Rosemary Stevens,
Corey Grimes, Will
Hines, Andy Rocco,
Stacy Mayer,
Mike Hagen

Votes:

12

Blue Team:

Kevin Hines, Alan Fessenden,
Rebekka Johnson, Brendan
Gallagher, Dave Warth,
Michael Jeffrey Cohen

Votes:

13

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

Annabelle's
Big Hunk

Matt
Donnelly

Date:

7/30/05

Masked
Improviser
Finals

Red Team:

Tiffany Morningstar,
Matt Pack, Will
Hines, Sean Taylor,
Mark Grenier,
Angela DeManti,
"Box Head"

Votes:

12

Blue Team:

Mo Fathelbab, Alan Fessenden,
Nick Gibbons, Kirk
Damato, Kevin Cragg,
Shannon Manning,
"Unknown Poultry"

Votes:

10

Winner:

Red

Candy:

Twix
Peanut
Butter

Bob
Acevedo

Date:

7/23/05

Red Team:

Tiffany Morningstar,
Anne Nodar, Dave
Warth, Devlyn Corrigan,
Michael Jeffrey Cohen,
Jarret Berenstein,
"The Gentleman"

Votes:

11

Blue Team:

Mo Fathelbab, Alan Fessenden,
Nick Gibbons, Kirk
Damato, Kevin Cragg,
Shannon Manning,
"Unknown Poultry"

Votes:

18

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

Snickers
Munch

Rosemary
Stevens

Date:

7/16/05

Red Team:

Tiffany Morningstar,
Anne Nodar, Dave
Warth, Devlyn Corrigan,
Jaime Skinner, Jarret
Berenstein,
"The Gentleman"

Votes:

17

Blue Team:

Garrett Palm, Michelle Dobrawsky,
Jessica Farmer, Kevin
Cragg, Jen MacNeil,
"Improv Ninja",
"Magical Improv Fairy"

Votes:

12

Winner:

Red

Candy:

Mars
Milky Way
Midnight

Erin Rose
Foley

Date:

7/9/05

Red Team:

Alan Fessenden, AJ Morales,
Pat Baer, Eden Gauteron,
Damon Ketron, Shannon Manning,
"Improv Panda"

Votes:

11

Blue Team:

Michael Jeffrey Cohen,
Garrett Palm, Michelle Dobrawsky,
Jessica Farmer, Kevin
Cragg, Jen MacNeil,
"Magical Improv Fairy"

Votes:

16

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

Hershey's
S'mores

Rosemary
Stevens

Date:

7/2/05

Red Team:

Rosemary Stevens, Dave Warth,
Lemar McLean, Sean Taylor,
Ernie Privetera, Tony Carnevale,
"Mystery Improviser"

Votes:

7

Blue Team:

Gavin Speiller,
Will Hines, Michelle Dobrawsky,
Jessica Farmer, Kevin
Cragg, Jen MacNeil,
"Magical Improv Fairy"

Votes:

25

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

Nestle
Butterfinger
Crisp

Stacy
Mayer

Date:

6/25/05

Red Team:

Rosemary Stevens, Dave Warth,
Lemar McLean, Sean Taylor,
Ernie Privetera, Tony Carnevale,
"Mystery Improviser"

Votes:

15

Blue Team:

Michael Jeffery Cohen, T.J. Allard,
Ashley Sronce, Guy Cohen,
Federico Garduño, Angela
Demanti, "Improviser X"

Votes:

7

Winner:

Red

Candy:

Nestle
Chunky

Michelle
Dobrawsky

Date:

6/18/05

Red Team:

Kevin Cragg, Matt Evans,
Jeff Scherer, Kirk Damato,
Gavin Speiller, Tony Carnevale

Votes:

23

Blue Team:

Eugene Cordero, Rosemary
Stevens, Amanda Allen,
Erik Tanouye, Steve
Kornstein, Louie Pearlman

Votes:

10

Winner:

Red

Candy:

Reese's
Nut-
Rageous

Shannon
Manning

Date:

6/11/05

Red Team:

Jen MacNeil, Mike Sleap,
Guy Cohen, Kelleigh Miller,
Shelly Stover, Eugene Cordero

Votes:

12

Blue Team:

Sean Taylor, Alan
Fessenden, Amanda Allen,
Ptolemy Slocum, Steve
Kornstein, Louie Pearlman

Votes:

16

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

Hershey's
Take 5

Rebekka
Johnson

Date:

6/4/05

Red Team:

Kevin Cragg, Jodi Skeris,
Jawnee Conroy, Eden
Gauteron, Ashley Sronce,
Devlyn Corrigan

Votes:

12

Blue Team:

LeMar McLean, Alan
Fessenden, Amanda Allen,
Ptolemy Slocum, Steve
Kornstein, Louie Pearlman

Votes:

14

Winner:

Blue

Date:

5/28/05

Red Team:

Sean Taylor, Pat Baer,
Gavin Speiller, Nick
Gibbons, Joe Miloscia
Miriam Siddiq

Votes:

12

Blue Team:

LeMar McLean, Alan
Fessenden, Amanda Allen,
Ptolemy Slocum, Steve
Kornstein, Louie Pearlman

Votes:

23

Winner:

Blue

Candy:

Hershey's
Whatcha-
macallit

Tiffany
Morningstar

Date:

5/21/05

Red Team:

Sean Taylor, Pat Baer,
Ryan Rogers, Shannon
Manning, Jen MacNeil
Sarah Yorra

Votes:

11

Blue Team:

LeMar McLean, Alan
Fessenden, Curtis Gwinn,
Ptolemy Slocum, Steve
Kornstein, Louie Pearlman

Votes:

21

Winner:

Blue

Date:

5/14/05

Red Team:

Benjamin Drazen,
Rosemary Stevens,
Aaron Heller, Molly
Robertson, Michael
Jeffrey Cohen, Madeline Lavrentjev

Votes:

2

Blue Team:

LeMar McLean, Alan
Fessenden, Curtis Gwinn,
Ptolemy Slocum, Steve
Kornstein, Louie Pearlman

Votes:

20

Winner:

Blue

Date:

5/7/05

Red Team:

Matt Pack, Matt Evans,
Pat Baer, Tiffany
Morningstar, Louie
Pearlman, Andy Rocco

Votes:

9

Blue Team:

LeMar McLean, Alan
Fessenden, Curtis Gwinn,
John Gemberling, Steve
Kornstein, Zach Tabacco

Votes:

18

Winner:

Blue

Date:

4/30/05

Red Team:

Jeff Scherer, Erin
Rose Foley, Justin Lang
Amanda Allan, Michelle
Medlin, Matt Evans

Votes:

11

Blue Team:

LeMar McLean, Alan
Fessenden, Jessica Allen,
Rich Sommer, Nick
Gibbons, Kevin Cragg

Votes:

18

Winner:

Blue

Date:

4/23/05

Red Team:

Jeff Scherer, Will
Hines, Erik Tanouye
Will Koehl, Evan
Batista, Dominic Dierkes

Votes:

12

Blue Team:

Shannon Manning, Alan
Fessenden, Dave Lombard,
J.B. Roté, Colin
Beckett, Kevin Cragg

Votes:

13

Winner:

Blue

Date:

4/16/05
one time
"Super Skirmish"

Red Team:

Jessica Allen
Dave Furfero
Eliza Skinner
Kevin Cragg
Federico Garduño
Nick Gibbons
Alan Fessenden
Ken Blackwell
Julie Brister
Rachael Mason
Rob Webber
Justin Lang

Votes:

19

Blue Team:

Jonathan Tea
Chris Himes
Jarret Berenstein
Molly Robertson
Mo Fathelbab
Erika Kern
Steve Kornstein
Ptolemy Slocum
Alex Marino
Will Koehl
Bob Acevedo
Dave Lombard

Votes:

18

Winner:

Red

Date:

3/26/05

Red Team:

Jeff Scherer, Rebekka
Johnson, Alex Marino
Michelle Dobrawsky, LeMar
McLean, Phil Shane

Votes:

10

Blue Team:

Shannon Manning, Alan
Fessenden, Dave Lombard,
J.B. Roté, Colin
Beckett, Kevin Cragg

Votes:

26

Winner:

Blue

Date:

3/19/05

Red Team:

Nate Shelkey, Rebekka
Johnson, Sean Taylor
Dave Thunder, LeMar
McLean, Phil Shane

Votes:

29

Blue Team:

Jen Hammaker, Erin
Rose Foley, Dan Goodman,
Bob Acevedo, Dave
Furfero, Ben Schwartz

Votes:

7

Winner:

Red

Date:

3/12/05

Red Team:

Nate Shelkey, Rebekka
Johnson, Sean Taylor
Dave Thunder, LeMar
McLean, Phil Shane

Votes:

27

Blue Team:

Tony Carnevale, Stacy
Mayer, Tamra Malaga,
Tiffany Morningstar, Michael
Jeffrey Cohen, Federico Garduño

Votes:

11

Winner:

Red

Date:

3/5/05

Red Team:

Dave Lombard, Alan
Fessenden, Jen MacNeil
John Gemberling, Pat Baer,
Marian Rosin

Votes:

18

Blue Team:

Tony Carnevale, Bob
Acevedo, Tamra Malaga,
Ben Schwartz, Michael
Jeffrey Cohen, Erik
Tanouye

Votes:

19

Winner:

Blue

Date:

2/26/05

Red Team:

Eason Smith, Amanda
Allan, Maddy Mako
Sean Taylor, Jeff Scherer,
Devlyn Corrigan

Votes:

4

Blue Team:

Tony Carnevale, Bob
Acevedo, Rachael Mason,
Ben Schwartz, Ernie
Privetera, Erik Tanouye

Votes:

11

Winner:

Blue

Date:

2/19/05

Red Team:

Eason Smith, Amanda
Allan, Maddy Mako
Sean Taylor, Jeff Scherer,
Devlyn Corrigan

Votes:

19

Blue Team:

Pat Baer, Will Nunziata,
Kevin Cragg,
Federico Garduño, Dan
Goodman, LeMar McLean

Votes:

7

Winner:

Red

Date:

2/12/05

Red Team:

Kevin Hines, Shannon
Manning, Michael Jeffrey
Cohen, Zach Tabacco,
Tiffany Morningstar, Erik
Tanouye

Votes:

3

Blue Team:

Pat Baer, Dave
Lombard, Kevin Cragg,
Federico Garduño, Dan
Goodman, LeMar McLean

Votes:

17

Winner:

Blue

Date:

2/5/05

Red Team:

Kevin Hines, Will Hines,
Michael Jeffrey Cohen,
Zach Tabacco, Tiffany
Morningstar, Erik Tanouye

Votes:

17

Blue Team:

Sean Taylor, Jen
Hammaker, Rob Cacy,
Brendan Gallagher, Alan
Fessenden, Maddy Mako

Votes:

5

Winner:

Red

Date:

1/29/05

Red Team:

Kevin Hines, Will Hines,
Jamie Rivera, Zach Tabacco,
Tiffany Morningstar, Erik Tanouye

Votes:

19

Blue Team:

Corrine Ellingson, Dave
Furfero, Amanda
Allan, Matt Donnelly
Erika Kern, Ben Schwartz

Votes:

9

Winner:

Red

Date:

1/22/05

Red Team:

Kevin Hines, Will Hines,
Jamie Rivera, Zach Tabacco,
Tiffany Morningstar, Erik Tanouye

Votes:

12

Blue Team:

Amanda Allan, Alan
Fessenden, Brendan
Gallagher, Stacy Mayer
Jen MacNeil, Sean Taylor

Votes:

2

Winner:

Red

Date:

1/15/05

Red Team:

Erin Rose Foley, Will Hines,
Rebekka Johnson, Stacy Mayer,
Gavin Speiller, Erik Tanouye

Votes:

5

Blue Team:

Amanda Allan, Alan
Fessenden, Brendan
Gallagher, Sue Galloway,
Jen MacNeil, Sean Taylor

Votes:

13

Winner:

Blue

Date:

1/8/05

Red Team:

Erin Rose Foley, Will Hines,
Rebekka Johnson, Stacy Mayer,
Gavin Speiller, Erik Tanouye

Votes:

12

Blue Team:

Tony Carnevale, Kevin Cragg,
Matt Donnelly, Jen MacNeil,
Alex Marino, Matt Pack

Votes:

8

Winner:

Red